One of my clients, a mother-doctor in family medicine, schedules Fridays off. This is a regularly scheduled non-clinical day to catch up on paperwork and administrative work related to patient care, and attending to the life’s work that would enable her to be home to welcome her two kids from school with dinner almost done.

Despite the logic of having Fridays off, she still felt guilty about having these days set aside for family life when she could be seeing more patients in her busy downtown practice.
In fact, one of her patients had mentioned, “by the way, I couldn’t see you last week when I felt pain in my foot because your secretary said you weren’t working that day.” I asked her to describe the narrative going through her head when her patient said this to her. She didn’t hesitate. It went something like: “You were at Costco on Friday when your patient was sitting in the ER! What are your priorities? Why weren’t you just working? Don’t you care about patient access?”
I know that voice. If you’re a mother-doctor, I’m guessing you know it too.
The problem: we call it guilt, but it’s usually shame
Most of us use “guilt” as a catch-all phrase. Mom guilt. Doctor guilt. Part-time guilt. Guilt for sitting down.
But according to Dr. Brené Brown, guilt and shame are not the same thing, and the difference matters more than you’d think.
- Guilt is focused on your behaviour. “I didn’t leave an open slot this week, so my patient had to wait a long time in the ER for a test I probably could have ordered for her.”
- Shame is focused on you as a person. “I’m a bad doctor. I’m so lazy. I’m a failure.”
Same situation. Completely different message.
When I explained this to my client and asked whether her patient’s comment made her experience guilt or shame, her answer was immediate: “Shame. For sure.”
She’s not alone. Medicine is a shame-based culture. We were trained to normalize the pain. Just the other day, one of my ER colleagues took on an evening shift before their already scheduled overnight shift! That’s 16 hours of emergency medicine. And the accolades came. “Amazing team player!” or “Go Dr. X, true warrior!” etc. etc. If you set a boundary, that behaviour gets read as a lack of dedication. Even when you know that the culture is toxic (and my client absolutely did), you still want to do more.
Here’s where you get blocked: you start to think that the harsh voice is what keeps you working hard and performing well at your job. But shame doesn’t make you a better doctor or a better mom. The harsh voice just makes you a more exhausted one.
Key Takeaway: move from “who I am” to “what I did”
The distinction between being guilt-prone vs. shame prone actually matters. When you focus on your behaviours, you have the ability to exert some intention on how you behave.
But if your focus is on who you are, you’re kind of stuck. What’s the solution? Be a different person? Not be your amazing self?!
If your thought is “I’m a terrible doctor,” what do you do with that thought (other than beat yourself up)?
If your thought is “My schedule doesn’t have room for urgent patients,” now you have options:
- Hold a same-week emergency slot or two
- Ask your administrative staff to suggest a booking template that builds in buffer
- Use a shared same-day access system with colleagues (if your clinic has one) so that even if they can’t see you, they can see another doctor who could pitch in
- Try a new tool that cuts down your charting time
Research on shame, including Brené Brown’s work that my Daring Way™ training is built on, links shame-based self-talk with higher rates of burnout, anxiety and depression. Focusing on behaviour, on the other hand, is protective.
Think about how you’d talk to your child after a failed test. You wouldn’t tell them they’re an idiot. You’d say, “Let’s look at your study habits. Maybe fewer late nights before the test. Maybe start a week earlier.” That’s guilt: honest, specific, and fixable.
You’d want your kids to be guilt-prone, not shame-prone. And whatever you model for yourself, you model for them.
The problem that results: catching the shame voice takes practice
Now that you know the difference between shame and guilt, can you start to see the difference in real time?
It shows up fast, especially when a patient is rude, a colleague seems to be doing more, or your kid says, “You’re never home.” My client said it plainly: even after she’d made peace with not having clinic on Fridays, she still hears the comments. She just doesn’t feel as bothered by them now. It took time.
Shame resilience is a skill, not a switch. It’s a lifetime of practice.
Your next step
This week, if someone complains about you not being available to help them, ask yourself one question:
“Is this about what I did, or who I am?”
If it’s about who you are, rewrite it as a behaviour. “I’m failing my patients” becomes “I need a better system for urgent bookings.” Then pick one small change to try.
And if this post made you think of a fellow mother-doctor who’s carrying too much, would you consider forwarding this blog to her? Sometimes the kindest thing is letting someone know she’s not the only one.
Until next week,
Dawn
P.S. Next Thursday: find out what happened when my client did the math on going part-time, and found out money wasn’t the real blocker!